When to Call a Handyman vs. a Specialist

When something breaks or needs fixing in your home, one of the first questions you'll face is whether to call a handyman or a specialized contractor. Making the right choice can save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars while ensuring the job is done correctly and safely.

As a second-generation handyman with over 15 years of experience serving South Florida, I've seen homeowners struggle with this decision countless times. The good news is that understanding the difference between when to hire a handyman versus a specialist doesn't have to be complicated. This guide will help you make informed decisions about your home repair and improvement projects.

The key factor isn't just about the type of work, but about the complexity, scope, and potential risks involved in the project. Let's break down exactly which projects are perfect for a skilled handyman and when you need to bring in a licensed specialist.

Projects Perfect for Handymen

A skilled handyman is your best choice for small to medium-sized projects that require general knowledge across multiple trades. Handymen excel at versatility and can often complete several different tasks in a single visit, making them more cost-effective and convenient for homeowners with multiple minor repairs.

Minor Plumbing Repairs

Handymen are perfectly suited for common plumbing issues like fixing leaky faucets, replacing toilet components, installing new fixtures, or repairing drain issues. These tasks don't require major system modifications or extensive pipe work, making them ideal handyman projects. Our plumbing services cover all these routine repairs that keep your home running smoothly.

Drywall Patching and Painting

From small nail holes to larger wall repairs, drywall work is a handyman's bread and butter. We can patch holes, repair water damage, texture walls, and apply fresh paint to restore your walls to perfect condition. This type of work doesn't require specialized licensing and is often needed after other repairs or as part of regular maintenance.

Door and Window Services

Installing interior doors, replacing door hardware, fixing squeaky hinges, adjusting door frames, and installing window treatments are all well within a handyman's expertise. These projects require carpentry skills and attention to detail but don't involve structural modifications.

General Carpentry and Repairs

Our carpentry services include building shelves, installing crown molding, repairing cabinets, fixing squeaky floors, and other woodworking projects. These tasks require skill and experience but don't necessitate the specialized expertise of a licensed contractor.

• Fence repairs: Fixing broken boards, reinforcing posts, and gate adjustments
• Deck maintenance: Board replacement, railing repairs, and power washing
• Pressure washing: Cleaning driveways, patios, siding, and outdoor surfaces
• Minor electrical: Replacing outlets, switches, light fixtures, and ceiling fans (where code allows)
• Assembly and installation: Furniture, shelving units, TV mounts, and home organization systems

When to Call a Specialist

Certain projects require specialized licenses, advanced training, or carry significant safety risks that make them unsuitable for general handyman work. These situations demand the expertise of licensed contractors who specialize in specific trades.

Major Electrical Work

Electrical panel upgrades, whole-house rewiring, installing new circuits, or any work involving your home's main electrical service requires a licensed electrician. These projects involve complex code requirements and serious safety considerations. While handymen can replace fixtures and outlets, major electrical work is always specialist territory.

Structural Repairs and Modifications

Removing load-bearing walls, foundation repairs, major beam replacement, or any work that affects your home's structural integrity requires a licensed structural engineer and contractor. These projects involve calculations, permits, and inspections that only specialists are qualified to handle.

Roof Replacement and Major Repairs

While a handyman can repair small leaks or replace a few shingles, complete roof replacement or extensive roof repairs should be handled by licensed roofing contractors. They have specialized equipment, insurance, and expertise for this critical component of your home.

HVAC Installation and Major Repairs

Installing new air conditioning systems, replacing heating units, or performing major HVAC repairs requires specialized licensing and certification. These systems are complex, involve refrigerants and gas lines, and must meet strict building codes and efficiency standards.

Major Plumbing Projects

Sewer line replacement, major pipe rerouting, water heater installation, or any work involving your home's main plumbing systems should be handled by a licensed plumber. These projects often require permits and involve code compliance that goes beyond general handyman expertise.

Cost Comparison: Handyman vs. Specialist

Understanding the cost differences between handymen and specialists helps you budget appropriately and make informed decisions. While rates vary by location and project complexity, here's what you can typically expect in South Florida.

Handyman Service Costs

Handymen typically charge hourly rates ranging from $50-$100 per hour, or provide flat-rate pricing for specific projects. The advantage is versatility—a handyman can tackle multiple small projects in one visit, maximizing your investment. For example, in a single appointment, we might repair a leaky faucet, patch drywall, and install new door hardware.

Specialist Service Costs

Specialists generally command higher rates, often $100-$200+ per hour, plus materials. However, for complex projects within their specialty, they're worth every penny. They bring specialized tools, licenses, insurance, and expertise that ensure code compliance and quality work.

When Cost Savings Make Sense

Using a handyman for appropriate projects can save you 30-50% compared to calling individual specialists for minor repairs. However, attempting to save money by using a handyman for specialist work can backfire, potentially costing more in corrections, safety issues, or failed inspections.

How Denahan Handyman Services Bridges the Gap

One of the unique advantages of working with an experienced handyman service is our ability to assess projects accurately and coordinate with specialists when needed. We've built relationships with trusted local contractors over 15 years in business, ensuring you get quality work whether it's within our scope or requires a specialist.

Our Project Assessment Process

When you contact us about a project, we start with a thorough assessment. We'll visit your home, evaluate the scope of work, and provide honest recommendations. If a project requires specialized licensing or expertise beyond our capabilities, we'll tell you upfront and can often recommend qualified specialists we trust.

Coordinating Complex Projects

For larger projects like bathroom remodels, we serve as general contractors, coordinating the various trades needed. We handle the handyman aspects directly and bring in licensed specialists for electrical, plumbing, or other specialized work, managing the entire project timeline and ensuring everything meets code.

The Integrity Advantage

Our reputation is built on integrity and transparency. We never take on projects we're not qualified to handle, and we always prioritize your safety and satisfaction. This honest approach has earned us countless referrals and long-term relationships with South Florida homeowners.